.
![]()
![]()
![]()
Ban Hat Sieo, Thailand. A Thai Buddhist monk-to-be wearing a colourful traditional costume tumbles as he rides an elephant to bathe during an annual procession at Yom river: photo by Pongmanat Tasiri/EPA via the Guardian, 7 April 2015
![]()
Ban Hat Sieo, Thailand. A Thai Buddhist monk-to-be wearing a colourful traditional costume tumbles as he rides an elephant to bathe during an annual procession at Yom river: photo by Pongmanat Tasiri/EPA via the Guardian, 7 April 2015
![FILE - In this Feb, 12, 2015 file photo a Thai Buddhist monk gives water to a tiger from a bottle at the "Tiger Temple" in Saiyok district in Kanchanaburi province, west of Bangkok, Thailand. Wildlife officials have begun removing some of the 137 tigers held at the Buddhist temple after accusations that their caretakers were involved in illegal breeding and trafficking of the animals, as well as neglected them. Teunjai Noochdumrong, assistant deputy director of the Department of National Parks, said three tigers had been tranquilized and transported Monday, May 30, 2016, in an operation involving about 1,000 state personnel and expected to go on for a week. Photo: Sakchai Lalit, AP / Copyright 2016 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistribu]()
![The carcasses of 40 tiger cubs found undeclared are displayed at the Wat Pha Luang Ta Bua Tiger Temple on June 1, 2016 in Kanchanaburi province, Thailand. Wildlife authorities in Thailand raided a Buddhist temple in Kanchanaburi province where 137 tigers were kept, following accusations the monks were illegally breeding and trafficking endangered animals. Forty of the 137 tigers were rescued by Tuesday from the country's infamous 'Tiger Temple' despite opposition from the temple authorities.]()
The carcasses of 40 tiger cubs found undeclared are displayed at the Wat Pha Luang Ta Bua Tiger Temple on June 1, 2016 in Kanchanaburi province, Thailand. Wildlife authorities in Thailand raided a Buddhist temple in Kanchanaburi province where 137 tigers were kept, following accusations the monks were illegally breeding and trafficking endangered animals. Forty of the 137 tigers were rescued by Tuesday from the country’s infamous ‘Tiger Temple’ despite opposition from the temple authorities.: photo by Thailand Department of National Parks, Wildlife and Plant Conservation via CNN, 1 June 2016
BANGKOK — Forty dead tiger cubs were found Wednesday in a freezer at a Buddhist temple that operated as an admission-charging zoo, a national parks official said.
The discovery happened while authorities were removing mostly full-grown live tigers from the temple in western Kanchanaburi province following accusations that monks were involved in illegal breeding and trafficking of the animals.
The cubs were found in a freezer where the temple staff kept food, said Anusorn Noochdumrong, an official from the Department of National Parks who has been overseeing the transfer of the temple's 137 tigers to shelters. Since Monday, 60 have been tranquilized and removed.
"We don't know why the temple decided to keep these cubs in the freezer," Anusorn said.
"We will collect these carcasses for DNA analysis."
The cubs appeared to be up to a week old, he said. Authorities plan to file charges against the temple for illegally possessing endangered species, he said.
The temple's Facebook page said in March that the temple's former vet had decided in 2010 to stop cremating cubs that died soon after birth. Calls to the temple's office were not answered.
The temple, a popular tourist attraction, has been criticized by animal rights activists because of allegations it is not properly set up to care for the animals and flouted regulations restricting the trade of tigers.
The monks resisted previous efforts to take away the tigers, but relented this week after police obtained a court order.
The temple recently made arrangements to operate as a zoo, but the plan fell through when the government determined that the operators failed to secure sufficient resources.
![]()
![]()
The carcasses of 40 tiger cubs were found at Wat Pha Luang Ta Bua, a Buddhist site widely known as the Tiger Temple, in Kanchanaburi, Thailand: photo by Dario Pignatelli/The New York Times, 1 June 2016
![Officials prepare weapons with a sedation as they start moving tigers from Thailand's controversial Tiger Temple, a popular tourist destination which has come under fire in recent years over the welfare of its big cats in Kanchanaburi province, west of Bangkok, Thailand, May 30, 2016. Wildlife authorities raid a Buddhist temple that has more than 100 tigers, taking away three cats and vowing to confiscate scores more in response to global pressure over wildlife trafficking. (Photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters)]()
Officials prepare weapons with a sedation as they start moving tigers from Thailand's controversial Tiger Temple, a popular tourist destination which has come under fire in recent years over the welfare of its big cats in Kanchanaburi province, west of Bangkok, Thailand. Wildlife authorities raid a Buddhist temple that has more than 100 tigers, taking away three cats and vowing to confiscate scores more in response to global pressure over wildlife trafficking.: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters, 30 May 2016
![A Buddhist monk walks past a tiger before officials start moving them from Thailand's controversial Tiger Temple, a popular tourist destination which has come under fire in recent years over the welfare of its big cats in Kanchanaburi province, west of Bangkok, Thailand, May 30, 2016. (Photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters)]()
A Buddhist monk walks past a chained and sedated tiger before officials start moving tigers from Thailand's controversial Tiger Temple, a popular tourist destination which has come under fire in recent years over the welfare of its big cats in Kanchanaburi province, west of Bangkok, Thailand: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters, 30 May 2016
![A tourist poses next to a tiger before officials start moving tigers from Thailand's controversial Tiger Temple, a popular tourist destination which has come under fire in recent years over the welfare of its big cats in Kanchanaburi province, west of Bangkok, Thailand, May 30, 2016. (Photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters)]()
A tourist poses next to a a chained and sedated tiger before officials start moving tigers from Thailand's controversial Tiger Temple, a popular tourist destination which has come under fire in recent years over the welfare of its big cats in Kanchanaburi province, west of Bangkok, Thailand: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters, 30 May 2016
![A sedated tiger is stretchered as officials start moving tigers from Thailand's controversial Tiger Temple, a popular tourist destination which has come under fire in recent years over the welfare of its big cats in Kanchanaburi province, west of Bangkok, Thailand, May 30, 2016. (Photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters)]()
A sedated tiger is stretchered as officials start moving tigers from Thailand's controversial Tiger Temple, a popular tourist destination which has come under fire in recent years over the welfare of its big cats in Kanchanaburi province, west of Bangkok, Thailand: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters, 30 May 2016
![A sedated tiger is stretchered as officials start moving tigers from Tiger Temple, May 30, 2016. The government introduced new animal welfare laws in 2015 aimed at curbing animal abuse, but activists accuse authorities of not enforcing the legislation properly. (Photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters)]()
A sedated tiger is stretchered as officials start moving tigers from Tiger Temple. The government introduced new animal welfare laws in 2015 aimed at curbing animal abuse, but activists accuse authorities of not enforcing the legislation properly.: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters, 30 May 2016
![A sedated tiger is stretchered as officials start moving tigers from Tiger Temple, May 30, 2016. The Buddhist temple in Kanchanaburi province west of Bangkok has more than 100 tigers and has become a tourist destination where visitors take selfies with tigers and bottle-feed their cubs. (Photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters)]()
A sedated tiger is stretchered as officials start moving tigers from Tiger Temple. The Buddhist temple in Kanchanaburi province west of Bangkok has more than 100 tigers and has become a tourist destination where visitors take selfies with tigers and bottle-feed their cubs.: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters, 30 May 2016
![Officials try to lead a tiger into a cage as they start moving tigers from Tiger Temple, May 30, 2016. Wildlife activists have accused the temple's monks of illegally breeding tigers, while some visitors have said the animals can appear drugged. The temple denies the accusations. (Photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters)]()
Officials try to lead a tiger into a cage as they start moving tigers from Tiger Temple, May 30, 2016. Wildlife activists have accused the temple's monks of illegally breeding tigers, while some visitors have said the animals can appear drugged. The temple denies the accusations.: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters, 30 May 2016
![A sedated tiger is stretchered as officials start moving tigers from Tiger Temple, May 30, 2016. (Photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters)]()
A sedated tiger is stretchered as officials start moving tigers from Tiger Temple: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters, 30 May 2016
![A sedated tiger is seen in a cage as officials start moving tigers from Thailand's controversial Tiger Temple, a popular tourist destination which has come under fire in recent years over the welfare of its big cats in Kanchanaburi province, west of Bangkok, Thailand, May 30, 2016. (Photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters)]()
A sedated tiger is seen in a cage as officials start moving tigers from Thailand's controversial Tiger Temple, a popular tourist destination which has come under fire in recent years over the welfare of its big cats in Kanchanaburi province, west of Bangkok, Thailand: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters, 30 May 2016 ![]()
A sedated tiger is placed on a stretcher as officials start removing tigers from Thailand's controversial temple in Kanchanaburi province: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom / Reuters, 30 May 2016
The Buddhist temple in Kanchanaburi province west of Bangkok had more than 130 tigers and had become a tourist destination where visitors took selfies with tigers and bottle-fed cubs.
The temple promoted itself as a wildlife sanctuary, but in recent years it had been investigated for suspected links to wildlife trafficking and animal abuse.
Wildlife activists have accused the temple's monks of illegally breeding tigers, while some visitors have said the animals can appear drugged. The temple denies the accusations.
The raid, which began on Monday, was the latest move by authorities in a tug-of-war since 2001 to bring the tigers under state control.
Adisorn Nuchdamrong, deputy director-general of the Department of National Parks, said his team was able to confiscate the tigers thanks to a warrant obtained a few hours before the operation began.
We have a court warrant this time, unlike previous times, when we only asked for the temple's cooperation, which did not work," Adisorn told Reuters.
"International pressure concerning illegal wildlife trafficking is also part of why we're acting now."
Monks at the temple were not available for comment
Officials moved seven tigers from the temple on Monday and 33 on Tuesday, leaving 97 still there.
Adisorn said the department planned to remove all of the tigers and send them to state-owned sanctuaries. Officials also found also found six hornbills, which are protected birds, at a monk's residence, he said.
Monks at the temple were not available for comment.
Previous attempts to inspect the tigers were largely blocked by the temple's abbots but in January and February wildlife officials removed 10 tigers.
Thailand has long been a hub for the illicit trafficking of wildlife and forest products, including ivory. Exotic birds, mammals and reptiles, some of them endangered species, can often be found on sale in markets.
The government introduced new animal welfare laws in 2015 aimed at curbing animal abuse, but activists accuse authorities of not enforcing the legislation.
The group People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals said the temple was "hell for animals", which spent much of their lives in cement cells.
"The tigers ... should be transferred to suitable sanctuaries and facilities that can offer them a better life," the group said in its statement.
It called on tourists to stop visiting animal attractions at home or abroad.
![]()
Phet -- the Indochinese Tiger. Phet is a victim of illegal wildlife trade. Her mother was killed by poachers in February 2000. Her two brothers also did not survive. By the time she was just four days old, Phet had already been sold on four times by illegal traders. Capture stress, malnutrition, ringworm infestation and diarrhea had taken their toll on Phet. She was in extremely poor condition and had lost most of her hair when she was rescued. Phet has made a full recovery thanks to CWI's Tiger Adoption Programme. She will depend on human care for the rest of her life: photo by Mikhail Esteves, 15 October, 2007
![]()
Captured tiger cub, Thailand. This poor guy was at the "Tiger Temple" in Kanchanaburi province, Thailand. I don't recommend this trip at all. Although it sounds nice touching the tigers and taking their pictures it's not as cool as you may think. The big tigers look as if on drugs and they just lie there sleeping all day. It looks sad and somehow you feel that these animals are used commercially just to bring money to the monks. Some other people in this region started capturing/buying/getting tigers and now they are happy to present those in cages for tourists -- for money of course. It's very different than in a Zoo, at least in a Zoo they have a relatively big area for the tigers to move and are being taken care by professionals. Here are approx 15 tigers in chains -- the big ones sleeping all the time (strange) and tons of people visiting every day putting money in this monastery. I understand it's hot and the tigers have to do this every day, probably are very bored, but not a single tiger moving from approx 10 adults? Second, you are not allowed to take pictures of the big tigers (Imagine my shock to hear that after traveling so much). Some volunteer will take your hand and bring you behind the sleeping tigers and another volunteer will take your camera and take some snapshots of you touching the tiger. You do this for approx 5 big sleeping tigers, 2 photos per each tiger (one landscape and one portrait). Or you can buy the "Special Photo" treatment and they take the sleeping tiger head and put it in your lap and somebody takes a photo of that. My photos are with the tiger cubs, these have a different treatment than the adults. At least these seem like normal "alive" animals -- but still in chains.: photo by photo by Pavel, 9 September 2009
![]()
Tiger Temple, Kanchanaburi province, Thailand: photo by brett marlow, 22 February 2008
![]()
Captured Tiger Cub, Thailand: photo by Pavel, 9 September 2009
![]()
The tigers and me. At a zoo of sorts in Thailand -- it was billed as a Crocodile Farm, but there were two gorgeous tigers and some elephants that made the crocodiles seem boring: photo by Roberta Taylor, 9 May 2008
![]()
Beautiful [Captive tiger, Thailand]: photo by Roberta Taylor, 9 May 2008
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Baby Tiger (Tiger Temple, Kanchanaburi Province, Thailand): photo by rogoyski, 3 January 2008
![]()
Tiger Temple, Kanchanaburi Province, Thailand: photo by SB, 21 November 2005
![]()
Tiger Temple 7 [Kanchanaburi Province, Thailand]: photo by audrey_sel, 2 January 2007
![]()
![]()
An enclosure at the Tiger Temple, an attraction in western Thailand that is affiliated with influential Buddhist monks.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 1 May 2016
![]()
An enclosure at the Tiger Temple, an attraction in western Thailand that is affiliated with influential Buddhist monks.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 1 May 2016
The tourists came next
![]()
Tigers cool off in a pool at the Tiger Temple, an attraction in western Thailand that officials promote as a place where animals coexist with humans in Buddhist harmony. Conservationists accuse the temple of abuse and exploitation.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
![]()
Tigers cool off in a pool at the Tiger Temple, an attraction in western Thailand that officials promote as a place where animals coexist with humans in Buddhist harmony. Conservationists accuse the temple of abuse and exploitation.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
![]()
A tiger with a handler in an outdoor enclosure at the temple, which began collecting animals 15 years ago when an abbot agreed to care for an injured tiger cub: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
![]()
![]()
The temple has 138 tigers -- not counting 10 that have been removed by the government -- and takes in millions of dollars from ticket sales each year.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
![]()
![]()
A monk accompanied tourists and staff members on a walk with one of the tigers. About 15 monks live on the grounds and have little to do with the tigers beyond occasionally posing with them for tourists.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
![]()
Tourists at the Tiger Temple. The government has ordered the temple to stop breeding tigers, charging fees to tourists and letting visitors feed tigers, officials say, but the temple has refused.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
![]()
Tourists at the Tiger Temple. The government has ordered the temple to stop breeding tigers, charging fees to tourists and letting visitors feed tigers, officials say, but the temple has refused.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
![]()
A staff member taking photos for tourists. A standard ticket, which costs about $17, entitles a visitor to walk a leashed tiger and pose with a chained tiger.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
![]()
A staff member taking photos for tourists. A standard ticket, which costs about $17, entitles a visitor to walk a leashed tiger and pose with a chained tiger.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
![]()
Staff members take tigers back to their enclosures after tourists have posed with them: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
![]()
Staff members take tigers back to their enclosures after tourists have posed with them: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
![]()
The tigers are kept in cages, although the temple also has large enclosures. “In Thailand, this is the best place for them,” a volunteer coordinator said. Conservationists and the government say otherwise.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
![]()
At ‘Tiger Temple,’ Thai Officials Seize 33 of the Big Cats: Tigers Seized in Raid on Buddhist Temple: Richard C. Paddock, The New York Times, 31 May 2016
The Wildlife Conservation Office this year ordered the temple to stop breeding tigers, selling tickets and allowing tourists to hand-feed the animals, but the temple ignored the orders. Ms. Teunchai has called the temple's abbot “a criminal” and said the monks acted as though they were above the law.
Buddhist monks pray during Makha Bucha Day in Chiang Mai, Thailand, to honor Buddha and his teachings on the day of the full moon in the third lunar month: photo by Athit Perawongmetha/Reuters, 22 February 2016
Buddhist monks pray during Makha Bucha Day in Chiang Mai, Thailand, to honor Buddha and his teachings on the day of the full moon in the third lunar month: photo by Athit Perawongmetha/Reuters, 22 February 2016
Ban Hat Sieo, Thailand. A Thai Buddhist monk-to-be wearing a colourful traditional costume tumbles as he rides an elephant to bathe during an annual procession at Yom river: photo by Pongmanat Tasiri/EPA via the Guardian, 7 April 2015
Ban Hat Sieo, Thailand. A Thai Buddhist monk-to-be wearing a colourful traditional costume tumbles as he rides an elephant to bathe during an annual procession at Yom river: photo by Pongmanat Tasiri/EPA via the Guardian, 7 April 2015
Mindful Tiger Temple Holocaust
In this 12 February 2015 file photo a Thai Buddhist monk gives water to a tiger from a bottle at the "Tiger Temple" in Saiyok district in Kanchanaburi province, west of Bangkok, Thailand. Wildlife officials have begun removing some of the 137 tigers held at the Buddhist temple after accusations that their caretakers were involved in illegal breeding and trafficking of the animals, as well as neglected them. Teunjai Noochdumrong, assistant deputy director of the Department of National Parks, said three tigers had been tranquilized and transported Monday, May 30, 2016, in an operation involving about 1,000 state personnel and expected to go on for a week.: photo by Sakchai Lalit/AP, 12 February 2015
The carcasses of 40 tiger cubs found undeclared are displayed at the Wat Pha Luang Ta Bua Tiger Temple on June 1, 2016 in Kanchanaburi province, Thailand. Wildlife authorities in Thailand raided a Buddhist temple in Kanchanaburi province where 137 tigers were kept, following accusations the monks were illegally breeding and trafficking endangered animals. Forty of the 137 tigers were rescued by Tuesday from the country’s infamous ‘Tiger Temple’ despite opposition from the temple authorities.: photo by Thailand Department of National Parks, Wildlife and Plant Conservation via CNN, 1 June 2016
Bodies of 40 tiger cubs found in Thai temple freezer:Tassanee Vejpongsa,Associated Press, 1 June 2016
BANGKOK — Forty dead tiger cubs were found Wednesday in a freezer at a Buddhist temple that operated as an admission-charging zoo, a national parks official said.
The discovery happened while authorities were removing mostly full-grown live tigers from the temple in western Kanchanaburi province following accusations that monks were involved in illegal breeding and trafficking of the animals.
The cubs were found in a freezer where the temple staff kept food, said Anusorn Noochdumrong, an official from the Department of National Parks who has been overseeing the transfer of the temple's 137 tigers to shelters. Since Monday, 60 have been tranquilized and removed.
"We don't know why the temple decided to keep these cubs in the freezer," Anusorn said.
"We will collect these carcasses for DNA analysis."
The cubs appeared to be up to a week old, he said. Authorities plan to file charges against the temple for illegally possessing endangered species, he said.
The temple's Facebook page said in March that the temple's former vet had decided in 2010 to stop cremating cubs that died soon after birth. Calls to the temple's office were not answered.
The temple, a popular tourist attraction, has been criticized by animal rights activists because of allegations it is not properly set up to care for the animals and flouted regulations restricting the trade of tigers.
The monks resisted previous efforts to take away the tigers, but relented this week after police obtained a court order.
The temple recently made arrangements to operate as a zoo, but the plan fell through when the government determined that the operators failed to secure sufficient resources.
The carcasses of 40 tiger cubs were found at Wat Pha Luang Ta Bua, a Buddhist site widely known as the Tiger Temple, in Kanchanaburi, Thailand: photo by Dario Pignatelli via The New York Times, 1 June 2016
![]()
.
The carcasses of 40 tiger cubs were found at Wat Pha Luang Ta Bua, a Buddhist site widely known as the Tiger Temple, in Kanchanaburi, Thailand: photo by Dario Pignatelli via The New York Times, 1 June 2016
. The carcasses of 40 tiger cubs were found at Wat Pha Luang Ta Bua, a Buddhist site widely known as the Tiger Temple, in Kanchanaburi, Thailand: photo by Dario Pignatelli via The New York Times, 1 June 2016
The carcasses of 40 tiger cubs were found at Wat Pha Luang Ta Bua, a Buddhist site widely known as the Tiger Temple, in Kanchanaburi, Thailand: photo by Dario Pignatelli/The New York Times, 1 June 2016
Thai Officials Find 40 Dead Cubs in Freezer at Tiger Temple: Richard C. Paddock, The New York Times, 1June 2016
BANGKOK — The Thai wildlife authorities found 40 dead tiger cubs in a freezer on Wednesday at the Tiger Temple, a controversial tourist attraction in western Thailand, and were investigating whether the carcasses were evidence of the temple’s involvement in the illegal wildlife trade.
The discovery came as Thai wildlife rangers were removing adult tigers from the temple in an effort to shut down the attraction after receiving complaints that the temple was trafficking in endangered species.
The temple, a Buddhist monastery that offered tourists close contact with tigers, has long been accused by conservationists and animal rights activists of exploiting and abusing the animals, accusations the temple has denied.
Wildlife officials said that only one of the dead cubs found on Wednesday had been reported to the government as required by law and that the police were investigating.
Tiger parts, while illegal to sell, are in high demand in Asia, particularly China, for use in traditional medicine. There is even a market for frozen tiger cubs, as the arrest last month of a Vietnamese man carrying four of them attests.
Representatives of the temple, Wat Pha Luang Ta Bua, said that Thailand’s Wildlife Conservation Office had been notified of all of the cubs’ births and deaths and that the bodies were kept as proof that none of them were sold on the black market.
“We have declared all the deaths to the officials over years,” said Supitpong Pakdjarung, a former police colonel who runs the temple’s business operation. “They’ve known about these carcasses for a long time.”
The temple has promoted itself as a spiritual center where people and tigers lived in harmony, and it has charged tourists as much as $140 apiece for the chance to bathe, hand-feed and play with the tigers.
The temple has promoted itself as a spiritual center where people and tigers lived in harmony, and has charged tourists as much as $140 apiece for the chance to play with the tigers
The temple was already under investigation on suspicion of illegally trading in tigers after a former veterinarian reported that three live adult tigers had vanished.
Adisorn Noochdumrong, deputy director general of the Department of National Parks, Wildlife and Plant Conservation, which oversees the Wildlife Conservation Office, said a temple staff member had told the authorities about the dead cubs in the freezer.
“We just found them this morning,” Mr. Adisorn said. “There are 40 tiger cubs.”
He said the department would perform DNA tests on the seized tigers and the dead cubs to see how they might be related.
Temple officials, however, denied any wrongdoing. Mr. Supitpong said he notified officials in December when they came to see how many tigers were at the temple.
“We just found them this morning. There are 40 tiger cubs.”
In a Facebook post in March, the temple said that it was normal for some cubs to die and that the staff had been preserving the carcasses since 2010. The post gave no indication of how many deceased cubs there were.
Teunchai Noochdumrong, director of Thailand’s Wildlife Conservation Office and the wife of Mr. Adisorn, said the cubs did not appear to be missing any parts. There was no indication yet how they died, she said.
Debbie Banks, campaign leader on tigers and wildlife crime for the London-based Environmental Investigative Agency, said the discovery of the cubs was disturbing given the underground market in frozen cubs.
While adult tigers have more value, particularly for their pelts, teeth and claws, the cubs can be sold for their meat and for their bones, which are said to have medicinal value, she said.
Tiger cubs also are sold in large jars of wine, either on their own or with bear paws, snakes and scorpions, she said. Some people believe such “wildlife wine” provides a health benefit, she said.
Zoos that offer tourists close contact with the animals and selfie opportunities are often fronts for breeding operations that supply the black market trade, Ms. Banks said.
“Forty frozen tiger cubs? Why would you keep them? It suggests something far more sinister.”
“Forty frozen tiger cubs?” she asked. “Why would you keep them? When we know there is a market for frozen tiger cubs, it raises a lot of issues. I think it suggests something far more sinister.”
At its peak, the temple reported having 148 tigers, nearly all of them adults. The wildlife agency seized 10 of the big cats earlier this year before the temple won a court order halting the operation. After the authorities successfully challenged that order, they resumed removing the animals on Monday.
By Wednesday evening, rangers had taken 64 more tigers, Ms. Teunchai said. The authorities estimated that 73 tigers remained at the zoo and hoped to have all of them removed by Saturday. They said that the temple lacked documentation proving ownership of the tigers and that therefore, under Thai endangered species law, they belonged to the government.
By Wednesday, Mr. Supitpong appeared resigned to the tigers’ removal and the closure of the temple’s tourist attraction. The temple recently won approval to build and operate a zoo on a nearby site, and Mr. Supitpong said he was ready to move forward with that plan.
“Right now, we want everything to come to an end,” he said. “Please hurry and remove all the tigers. Once the state tigers are all removed, we will proceed with the zoo.”
The Heat Closing In On Mindful Tiger Temple
Officials prepare weapons with a sedation as they start moving tigers from Thailand's controversial Tiger Temple, a popular tourist destination which has come under fire in recent years over the welfare of its big cats in Kanchanaburi province, west of Bangkok, Thailand. Wildlife authorities raid a Buddhist temple that has more than 100 tigers, taking away three cats and vowing to confiscate scores more in response to global pressure over wildlife trafficking.: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters, 30 May 2016
A Buddhist monk walks past a chained and sedated tiger before officials start moving tigers from Thailand's controversial Tiger Temple, a popular tourist destination which has come under fire in recent years over the welfare of its big cats in Kanchanaburi province, west of Bangkok, Thailand: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters, 30 May 2016
A tourist poses next to a a chained and sedated tiger before officials start moving tigers from Thailand's controversial Tiger Temple, a popular tourist destination which has come under fire in recent years over the welfare of its big cats in Kanchanaburi province, west of Bangkok, Thailand: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters, 30 May 2016
A sedated tiger is stretchered as officials start moving tigers from Thailand's controversial Tiger Temple, a popular tourist destination which has come under fire in recent years over the welfare of its big cats in Kanchanaburi province, west of Bangkok, Thailand: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters, 30 May 2016
A sedated tiger is stretchered as officials start moving tigers from Tiger Temple. The government introduced new animal welfare laws in 2015 aimed at curbing animal abuse, but activists accuse authorities of not enforcing the legislation properly.: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters, 30 May 2016
A sedated tiger is stretchered as officials start moving tigers from Tiger Temple. The Buddhist temple in Kanchanaburi province west of Bangkok has more than 100 tigers and has become a tourist destination where visitors take selfies with tigers and bottle-feed their cubs.: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters, 30 May 2016
Officials try to lead a tiger into a cage as they start moving tigers from Tiger Temple, May 30, 2016. Wildlife activists have accused the temple's monks of illegally breeding tigers, while some visitors have said the animals can appear drugged. The temple denies the accusations.: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters, 30 May 2016
A sedated tiger is stretchered as officials start moving tigers from Tiger Temple: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters, 30 May 2016
A sedated tiger is seen in a cage as officials start moving tigers from Thailand's controversial Tiger Temple, a popular tourist destination which has come under fire in recent years over the welfare of its big cats in Kanchanaburi province, west of Bangkok, Thailand: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom/Reuters, 30 May 2016
A sedated tiger is placed on a stretcher as officials start removing tigers from Thailand's controversial temple in Kanchanaburi province: photo by Chaiwat Subprasom / Reuters, 30 May 2016
Big cats removed from Thailand's infamous Tiger Temple: Patpicha Tanakasempipat, Reuters, 31 May 2016
KANCHANABURI, Thailand -- Wildlife authorities in Thailand have raided a Buddhist temple where tigers are kept, taking away 40 of the animals by Tuesday and vowing to confiscate scores more in response to global pressure over wildlife trafficking.The Buddhist temple in Kanchanaburi province west of Bangkok had more than 130 tigers and had become a tourist destination where visitors took selfies with tigers and bottle-fed cubs.
The temple promoted itself as a wildlife sanctuary, but in recent years it had been investigated for suspected links to wildlife trafficking and animal abuse.
Wildlife activists have accused the temple's monks of illegally breeding tigers, while some visitors have said the animals can appear drugged. The temple denies the accusations.
The raid, which began on Monday, was the latest move by authorities in a tug-of-war since 2001 to bring the tigers under state control.
Adisorn Nuchdamrong, deputy director-general of the Department of National Parks, said his team was able to confiscate the tigers thanks to a warrant obtained a few hours before the operation began.
We have a court warrant this time, unlike previous times, when we only asked for the temple's cooperation, which did not work," Adisorn told Reuters.
"International pressure concerning illegal wildlife trafficking is also part of why we're acting now."
Monks at the temple were not available for comment
Officials moved seven tigers from the temple on Monday and 33 on Tuesday, leaving 97 still there.
Adisorn said the department planned to remove all of the tigers and send them to state-owned sanctuaries. Officials also found also found six hornbills, which are protected birds, at a monk's residence, he said.
Monks at the temple were not available for comment.
Previous attempts to inspect the tigers were largely blocked by the temple's abbots but in January and February wildlife officials removed 10 tigers.
Thailand has long been a hub for the illicit trafficking of wildlife and forest products, including ivory. Exotic birds, mammals and reptiles, some of them endangered species, can often be found on sale in markets.
The government introduced new animal welfare laws in 2015 aimed at curbing animal abuse, but activists accuse authorities of not enforcing the legislation.
The group People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals said the temple was "hell for animals", which spent much of their lives in cement cells.
"The tigers ... should be transferred to suitable sanctuaries and facilities that can offer them a better life," the group said in its statement.
It called on tourists to stop visiting animal attractions at home or abroad.
Phet -- the Indochinese Tiger. Phet is a victim of illegal wildlife trade. Her mother was killed by poachers in February 2000. Her two brothers also did not survive. By the time she was just four days old, Phet had already been sold on four times by illegal traders. Capture stress, malnutrition, ringworm infestation and diarrhea had taken their toll on Phet. She was in extremely poor condition and had lost most of her hair when she was rescued. Phet has made a full recovery thanks to CWI's Tiger Adoption Programme. She will depend on human care for the rest of her life: photo by Mikhail Esteves, 15 October, 2007
Captured tiger cub, Thailand. This poor guy was at the "Tiger Temple" in Kanchanaburi province, Thailand. I don't recommend this trip at all. Although it sounds nice touching the tigers and taking their pictures it's not as cool as you may think. The big tigers look as if on drugs and they just lie there sleeping all day. It looks sad and somehow you feel that these animals are used commercially just to bring money to the monks. Some other people in this region started capturing/buying/getting tigers and now they are happy to present those in cages for tourists -- for money of course. It's very different than in a Zoo, at least in a Zoo they have a relatively big area for the tigers to move and are being taken care by professionals. Here are approx 15 tigers in chains -- the big ones sleeping all the time (strange) and tons of people visiting every day putting money in this monastery. I understand it's hot and the tigers have to do this every day, probably are very bored, but not a single tiger moving from approx 10 adults? Second, you are not allowed to take pictures of the big tigers (Imagine my shock to hear that after traveling so much). Some volunteer will take your hand and bring you behind the sleeping tigers and another volunteer will take your camera and take some snapshots of you touching the tiger. You do this for approx 5 big sleeping tigers, 2 photos per each tiger (one landscape and one portrait). Or you can buy the "Special Photo" treatment and they take the sleeping tiger head and put it in your lap and somebody takes a photo of that. My photos are with the tiger cubs, these have a different treatment than the adults. At least these seem like normal "alive" animals -- but still in chains.: photo by photo by Pavel, 9 September 2009
Tiger Temple, Kanchanaburi province, Thailand: photo by brett marlow, 22 February 2008
Captured Tiger Cub, Thailand: photo by Pavel, 9 September 2009
The tigers and me. At a zoo of sorts in Thailand -- it was billed as a Crocodile Farm, but there were two gorgeous tigers and some elephants that made the crocodiles seem boring: photo by Roberta Taylor, 9 May 2008
Beautiful [Captive tiger, Thailand]: photo by Roberta Taylor, 9 May 2008
Tiger, Tiger Kingdom, Phuket, Thailand: photo by Nicholas Vollmer, 14 January 2014
sedated tiger, Chiang Mai, Thailand: photo by garycycles7, 3 May 2011
Tiger Temple 3 [Kanchanaburi Province, Thailand]: photo by audrey_sel, 2 January 2007
Baby Tiger (Tiger Temple, Kanchanaburi Province, Thailand): photo by rogoyski, 3 January 2008
Tiger Temple, Kanchanaburi Province, Thailand: photo by SB, 21 November 2005
Tiger Temple 7 [Kanchanaburi Province, Thailand]: photo by audrey_sel, 2 January 2007
Tigers, Samphran Elephant Ground and Zoo, Ban Phaeo, Samut Sakran, Thailand: photo by Sophia Lucero, 3 June 2011
Burning Down the Mindful Tiger Temple Con
An enclosure at the Tiger Temple, an attraction in western Thailand that is affiliated with influential Buddhist monks.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 1 May 2016
An enclosure at the Tiger Temple, an attraction in western Thailand that is affiliated with influential Buddhist monks.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 1 May 2016
Thai Officials Battle Buddhist Monks Over Tigers’ Fate: Richard C. Paddock, The New York Times, 1 May 2016
SAI YOK, Thailand — Saira Tahir, a London lawyer, waved a bamboo pole with a plastic bag affixed to the end high in the air. A 200-pound tiger leapt and swatted it like a house cat batting a string toy.
For her $140 premium admission, Ms. Tahir also bathed a tiger, bottle-fed a cub and posed for a photo with a tiger’s head in her lap.
“It’s a surreal experience being so close to them,” she said. “Even with the tiger’s head in your lap, you can feel the energy. It’s not something you do every day.”
An Edenesque wildlife fantasy
Part Buddhist monastery and part petting zoo, the Tiger Temple in western Thailand has long been the bane of conservationists and animal rights activists who accuse it of abuse and exploitation even as it offers tourists an Edenesque wildlife fantasy.
Now, after complaints of trafficking in endangered species, the government is trying to shut down the attraction. But there are two major obstacles: the temple, which has gone to court to block the closing, and the tigers. What do you do with nearly 150 carnivorous cats raised in captivity?
The government began removing the tigers this year but was ordered to stop after the lawsuit was filed in February. Until the case is resolved, the fate of the tigers is mired in a legal standoff that pits wildlife officials, conservationists and Thailand’s military government against a wealthy tourist enterprise backed by influential Buddhist monks.
The Tiger Temple, in rural Kanchanaburi Province near the Myanmar border, started collecting animals 15 years ago with an act of charity. Villagers took an injured tiger cub to the local abbot, who agreed to care for it. Word spread, and soon there were six tigers.
The tourists came next
“We built this temple to spread Buddhism,” said Supitpong Pakdjarung, a former police colonel who runs the temple’s business arm. “The tigers came by themselves.”
The tourists came next. Today, the temple takes in $5.7 million a year from ticket sales, wildlife officials say, and receives millions more in donations. A standard ticket, about $17, entitles a visitor to walk a leashed tiger and pose with a chained tiger.
The 15 or so monks who live on the grounds have little to do with the tigers beyond occasionally posing with them for tourists. But a Buddhist atmosphere is part of the pitch. The temple promotes itself as a place where tigers betray their wild nature to coexist with humans in Buddhist harmony.
“We can live together peacefully because of kindness,” Mr. Supitpong said.
A Buddhist atmosphere is part of the pitch
Some monks and staff members believe that certain tigers are reincarnated monks or relatives. Mr. Supitpong said that through meditation, monks had come up with dietary solutions to repair genetic defects from inbreeding.
“It is a spiritual connection,” he said.
The Buddhist imprimatur also makes the temple a powerful adversary in its legal battle with the government. In Thailand, the moral authority of monks rivals the secular authority of the law.
“They have the power to say right or wrong in terms of morality,” said Surapot Taweesak, a scholar in philosophy and religion at Suan Dusit Rajabhat University in Bangkok. “This makes people listen and not dare to argue or debate with monks for fear of being sinful.”
The government has ordered the temple to stop breeding tigers, charging fees to tourists and letting visitors feed tigers, officials say, but the temple has refused.
“The monks have the attitude, ‘I am over the law’”
“The monks have the attitude, ‘I am over the law,’” said Teunchai Noochdumrong, the director of Thailand’s Wildlife Conservation Office. “They say because they are monks, they have the right to take care of all the animals in that area.”
The abbot, Phra Vissuthisaradhera, is “not a monk,” Ms. Teunchai said. “He’s a criminal.”
Mr. Vissuthisaradhera, who was attacked and clawed on the face last year by his favorite tiger, declined to be interviewed.
For years, the temple has faced allegations of misconduct. Recently, a handler was caught on video punching a tiger in the head.
“We have to hit them so we can change the tiger’s mood at the moment”
Mr. Supitpong acknowledges that staff members sometimes have to strike the tigers to distract them from focusing on tourists as prey. “We have to hit them so we can change the tiger’s mood at the moment,” he said.
Charges of tiger smuggling date to at least 2008, when the British group Care for the Wild said the temple was illegally trading tigers with a farm in neighboring Laos.
Last year, the temple’s veterinarian resigned and reported that three tigers had vanished from the temple. He handed over three microchips that he said had been removed from the tigers; such chips are used to track endangered animals.
An Australian organization, Cee4life, claims that 281 tigers have been born at the temple over the years and that natural deaths alone could not account for today’s population, which stands at 138, not counting the 10 already removed by the government. The organization also presented evidence that some of the temple’s first tigers had been caught in the wild and that others had been brought later from Laos.
Copycatting the temple’s business success
The temple’s business success has inspired dozens of other operators of unlicensed zoos to offer tourists close contact with rare animals, said Edwin Wiek, the founder of the Wildlife Friends Foundation Thailand.
The animals they breed are unwanted once they mature, Mr. Wiek said, contributing to Thailand’s role as a global hub for illegal trafficking in endangered animals.
Tiger parts are in high demand in Asia, particularly China, for use in traditional medicine. Tiger bone can fetch as much as $168 a pound, and tiger penis soup goes for as much as $320 a bowl.
“In the past we called it ‘monks feed tigers.’ But now it’s ‘tigers feed monks.’”
At the Tiger Temple, only tigers under age 4 -- there are 16 of them now -- are brought out for tourists. Larger tigers, which can be careless about the rules of interspecies harmony, are retired to cages.
After the veterinarian’s accusations, the government revoked the temple’s permission to keep tigers. The temple lacks documents proving ownership, so wildlife officials contend that the tigers belong to the government.
Temple officials deny abusing the tigers or trading in tigers or tiger parts. They lack ownership papers, they say, because most of the tigers were born at the temple.
Mr. Supitpong said that the three tigers suspected to be missing were still on the premises, and that he had no knowledge of any microchips being removed.
“We have received all the funds by the tigers’ virtue”
During a raid last year, government officials also found eight hornbills and six Asian black bears, also protected species. The temple said it was the legitimate owner of those animals, too, but lacked the documents proving it, Ms. Teunchai said.
When wildlife officials tried to seize the animals last year, protesting monks and temple supporters blocked the main road to the temple. Officials circumvented the protest by driving a crane to the side of the temple and hoisting the bears over a a 12-foot wall.
Mr. Supitpong says the temple earns $3 million a year in ticket revenue, about half what the government says. Most of the donations go toward the construction of a $29 million temple that is expected to be completed in 2022, the next Year of the Tiger. The temple will be one of Thailand’s largest.
“We have received all the funds by the tigers’ virtue,” Mr. Supitpong said. “In the past we called it ‘monks feed tigers.’ But now it’s ‘tigers feed monks.’”
“A tiger is a tiger, not a pet. They have to live their nature.”
There are about 2,000 captive tigers in Thailand, but most are a mix of Bengal tigers, a type that is native to the Indian subcontinent, and Indochinese tigers. Only an estimated 189 Indochinese tigers -- the subspecies native to the region -- remain in Thailand’s forests.
The crossbred tigers are of no value in protecting the species as a whole, conservationists say.
While the temple tigers are not domesticated -- their behavior can be unpredictable, and there have been several attacks on tourists and staff members -- they are not wild, either, having been raised in captivity and unafraid of people. If the Tiger Temple is shut down, the tigers cannot simply be set free in the jungle.
The 10 tigers removed by the government were taken by truck to a government center, the Khao Prathap Chang Wildlife Breeding Center, in neighboring Ratchaburi Province, where each has a 430-square-foot cage equipped with a concrete pool the size of a large bathtub. The cages, unlike those at the temple, have no access to an enclosure with grass and trees.
Temple officials insist that tigers are better off at the temple.
“In Thailand, this is the best place for them,” said Tanya Erzinclioglu, a volunteer coordinator.
But Banpot Maleehuan, the government center’s director, said ending the tigers’ close contact with people had already been good for them.
“They have been here two months now, and they are becoming real tigers,” he said. “A tiger is a tiger, not a pet. They have to live their nature.”
Tigers cool off in a pool at the Tiger Temple, an attraction in western Thailand that officials promote as a place where animals coexist with humans in Buddhist harmony. Conservationists accuse the temple of abuse and exploitation.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
Tigers cool off in a pool at the Tiger Temple, an attraction in western Thailand that officials promote as a place where animals coexist with humans in Buddhist harmony. Conservationists accuse the temple of abuse and exploitation.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
A tiger with a handler in an outdoor enclosure at the temple, which began collecting animals 15 years ago when an abbot agreed to care for an injured tiger cub: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
The temple has 138 tigers -- not counting 10 that have been removed by the government -- and takes in millions of dollars from ticket sales each year.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
The temple has 138 tigers -- not counting 10 that have been removed by the government -- and takes in millions of dollars from ticket sales each year.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
A monk accompanied tourists and staff members on a walk with one of the tigers. About 15 monks live on the grounds and have little to do with the tigers beyond occasionally posing with them for tourists.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
A monk accompanied tourists and staff members on a walk with one of the tigers. About 15 monks live on the grounds and have little to do with the tigers beyond occasionally posing with them for tourists.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
Tourists at the Tiger Temple. The government has ordered the temple to stop breeding tigers, charging fees to tourists and letting visitors feed tigers, officials say, but the temple has refused.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
Tourists at the Tiger Temple. The government has ordered the temple to stop breeding tigers, charging fees to tourists and letting visitors feed tigers, officials say, but the temple has refused.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
A staff member taking photos for tourists. A standard ticket, which costs about $17, entitles a visitor to walk a leashed tiger and pose with a chained tiger.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
A staff member taking photos for tourists. A standard ticket, which costs about $17, entitles a visitor to walk a leashed tiger and pose with a chained tiger.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
Staff members take tigers back to their enclosures after tourists have posed with them: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
Staff members take tigers back to their enclosures after tourists have posed with them: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
The tigers are kept in cages, although the temple also has large enclosures. “In Thailand, this is the best place for them,” a volunteer coordinator said. Conservationists and the government say otherwise.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
The tigers are kept in cages, although the temple also has large enclosures. “In Thailand, this is the best place for them,” a volunteer coordinator said. Conservationists and the government say otherwise.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 21 May 2016
BANGKOK — Wildlife authorities seized 33 tigers on Tuesday from a Buddhist temple in western Thailand in an effort to shut down the popular but controversial tourist attraction as early as this week.
Teunchai Noochdumrong, the director of Thailand’s Wildlife Conservation Office, said she was optimistic that all of the temple’s tigers, estimated to total 137, would be removed by Friday, ending a long-running dispute between the temple and the government.
The temple, Wat Pha Luang Ta Bua, commonly called the Tiger Temple, began keeping and breeding tigers 15 years ago and has promoted itself as a spiritual sanctuary where wild animals and humans can peacefully coexist. For years, it has been accused of misconduct and trading in endangered animals. It has earned nearly $6 million a year from ticket sales, officials said.
The Wildlife Conservation Office this year ordered the temple to stop breeding tigers, selling tickets and allowing tourists to hand-feed the animals, but the temple ignored the orders. Ms. Teunchai has called the temple's abbot “a criminal” and said the monks acted as though they were above the law.
The temple is also under investigation on suspicion of illegally trading in tigers after three of the animals vanished from the temple.
“Tomorrow we will have hard work because they unlocked the cages of all the tigers”
The government seized 10 tigers earlier this year, along with six Asian black bears and eight hornbills, before the temple won a temporary court order in February halting the removal of more tigers. At one point, monks and their supporters blocked the gate to the compound to prevent officials from taking the animals.
This week, after the agency obtained a court order directing the temple to hand over the tigers, the authorities removed seven tigers on Monday and 33 on Tuesday.
Three hundred agency staff members took part in the roundup, as well as police officers who were there to maintain order, Ms. Teunchai said.
Workers at the temple opened the tigers’ cages, allowing them to enter larger enclosures, making it harder to capture the remaining animals, Ms. Teunchai said.
“Tomorrow we will have hard work because they unlocked the cages of all the tigers,” she said.
Temple officials could not be reached for comment on Tuesday.
The tigers are being moved to government wildlife centers around the country.
![Embedded image permalink]()
![]()
A big cat skeleton -- allegedly a tiger -- in an aquarium of tiger bone wine, at Fantasy Garrett, a restaurant in the Golden Triangle Special Economic Zone: photo by EIA, 19 March 2015
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
The entrance to the Tiger Temple, which has been accused of mistreating and illegally trading tigers. Temple officials deny the allegations.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 1 May 2016
![]()
Thailand’s #TigerTemple under investigation for alleged engagement in illegal #wildlifetrade: image via Animal Protection UK @MoveTheWorldUK, 5 February 2016
A big cat skeleton -- allegedly a tiger -- in an aquarium of tiger bone wine, at Fantasy Garrett, a restaurant in the Golden Triangle Special Economic Zone: photo by EIA, 19 March 2015
A big cat skeleton -- allegedly a tiger -- in an aquarium of tiger bone wine, at Fantasy Garrett, a restaurant in the Golden Triangle Special Economic Zone: photo by EIA, 19 March 2015
A caged tiger bred for slaughter in the Golden Triangle Special Economic Zone: photo by EIA, 19 March 2015
A caged tiger bred for slaughter in the Golden Triangle Special Economic Zone: photo by EIA, 19 March 2015
The entrance to the Tiger Temple, which has been accused of mistreating and illegally trading tigers. Temple officials deny the allegations.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 1 May 2016
The entrance to the Tiger Temple, which has been accused of mistreating and illegally trading tigers. Temple officials deny the allegations.: photo by Amanda Mustard for The New York Times, 1 May 2016